As a past winner of the Doyles, I know what that prize can mean.
I was sitting in chair 9B, about to switch my phone to flight mode. "Hi Zac, it's the Doyles award here, can you give us a call when you can regarding your entry, we'd love to chat." Every young artist has heard the line "they'll call if you've won". I sat there, glazed over as the cabin crew pointed to the exits, could I really have won?
Flash forward a few days and I'm shaking the hand of Jennefer Doyle and holding up the 1st place award for the landscape category. It's hard for this painter (definitely not writer) to put into words the complexity of what that meant for me. This is not just a cash prize, it is validation. It is a career moment, it is a regional art prize body telling an emerging artist that what they do matters. As an artist, self-doubt and insecurity runs freely through my veins, imposter syndrome set to full. Emerging artists work outside the major institutional centres, this kind of recognition carries real weight. It opens doors, shifts confidence, helps sales and gives the artist a real sense of being seen for the years of hard work that leads to these moments.
That is why the recent controversy around the 2025 Doyles Award matters so much. This is not just about a sketchy artist (too good a pun not to use), or a panel of judges making a mistake. This speaks to a broader problem that I see within the Australian art scene itself. How easily we can mistake performance for authenticity and how often we confuse the language surrounding a work, with the truth of the work itself.
The reported facts speak for themselves, I don't think I need to embellish upon those. A painting awarded a major landscape prize has since been identified by organisers and commentators as a direct copy of a deceased contemporary Australian artist, Nicholas Harding. It has been accepted, judged, lauded, financially rewarded to the tune of $20,000 and publicly celebrated, all before these claims came to light. The institution then had to confront the possibility that its highest honour for the year has gone to a work that did not meet entry conditions. I feel for them, I really do. This is a volunteer-run, community-supported organisation that works incredibly hard to put on this major event each year. Wonderful, supportive people giving up their time and labour to build a genuine platform for artists.
The failure here is not only could a copied image win, it's that the system around the prize converts that image into authoritative originality. The artist's statement gave the work a backstory, the judging panel gave it authority, the award gave it financial and cultural value, social media and news outlets spread the word and the public accepts that this is a great, original Australian piece of art. Until it's not.
Art prizes ask us to rely on a set of checks and balances; the quality of the judges, the presentation both physically and digitally of the prize itself, the opening night and the celebration of the winners. These aren't really proof though, they're vibes. They give things a sense of importance without establishing any real truth. Painters understand the difference between influence and copying. Copying (and not entering into prizes) great art is a legitimate educational tool, like reading the great novelists, or covering your favourite song. We look hard, borrow ideas, remember things incorrectly and absorb all of art history in the hopes of finding new ways to represent familiar ideas. This is art. It's not enough to say after the fact, that the line between appropriation and influence is too blurry to differentiate.
When a prize is announced, it comes from the judges' decision. The institutions and the public rely on the judges' reputations to reassure that the artwork has undergone appropriate scrutiny. Their names lend credibility to the prize itself. This isn't a collective of people picking their fave, it's a group of industry professionals tasked with the decision of assigning value, credibility and above all else, validity within the broad landscape of Australian Contemporary painting. What a judge thinks matters, hugely. It can build sales, opportunities and careers. One of the more uncomfortable parts of this whole controversy is the fact that some of these judges are deeply embedded in this industry of cultural narrative, marketability and fostering of the future Australian Contemporary Art scene. It's not their responsibility to ensure artists don't copy, but they do need to be accountable for the cultural authority they applied to the work. What criteria matters here? Do you still stand by the decision you made? If a judge's public role is to identify authenticity, the grounds on which this decision was made should be clear.
At a time where artists are fighting battles on more fronts than ever; plagiarism, theft, AI, unauthorised reproductions. Prizes need to be setting very high standards, not discovering mishaps 12 months down the line. Due diligence is key, and I'm sure this situation has brought this to light for the many, many prizes associated with visual arts here in Australia. If public recognition is part of the prize, public accountability needs to go with it.
As a winner, I don't want to see the Doyles go down for this. I admire their proactivity in bringing this conversation to light, and asking us all to think about what the structure of the Australian art scene represents and how it can improve. This will require more than saying, "it's the artist's fault for not following the rules" because it's not just a financial impact that matters here. Artists that see a copy elevated above all other original works, lose trust in the institutions that claim to be supporting them. Our culture suffers when the story attached to the work becomes more important than the originality of the work itself.
The Australian art scene values authenticity? Prove it.
© Zac Moynihan 2026. All rights reserved.
This article may be quoted in short excerpts with clear attribution and a link to the original page. It may not be reproduced, republished, adapted, screenshotted in full, or used for commercial purposes without written permission.